Galileo's Mistake - A New Look at the Epic Confrontation between Galileo and the Church by Wade Rowland

Praise for Galileo's Mistake:

"...fresh and compelling."
Vancouver Sun

"Well-presented scientific history with an interesting philosophical twist"
Kirkus Reviews

"Rowland's is an audacious position"
The New York Times

"Rowland's triumph is in examining Galileo's method over his facts and winning an argument that was lost more than 350 years ago. His book provides a fascinating contribution to a debate that is particularly germane today and is likely to be equally important 300 years from now."
Montreal Gazette

"I recommend it strongly. Rowland tells the story well and with style and...backed by serious research and sensitivity to the issues. The history is embedded in a modern-day travelogue, interspersed with musings about the meaning of life."
The Globe and Mail

"Rowland does an impressive job of bringing the 17th century to life...he builds a compelling case that Galileo and the Church differed over something far more important than whether the earth revolved around the sun-they differed on the very nature of truth and how mortals can come to know it."
Publishers Weekly

"An excellent mixture of science and philosophy."
David Pitt, Bookloons

"Galileo's Mistake is a lofty and ambitious philosophical exploration, and Rowland's considerable gifts as a writer make the book pleasurable and captivating. Rowland skilfully weaves history, biography, science writing, and philosophical overviews into the comfortable familiarity of a travel narrative."

"Galileo's Mistake has the lazy ease of a multi-course Italian dinner, at once relaxing and enriching".
Robert Wiersema, Quill & Quire

"...a superb work...an ambitious, even heroic, interpretation of the Galileo-Church controversy. Rowland has included a wonderfully accurate, exquisitely painted presentation of the political, cultural, and historical setting in which the Galileo-Church debate finds a clearly natural location."
B. J. Hodgson, PhD, Trent University Faculty of Philosophy



Listen to interviews
of Wade Rowland

by CKNW Radio (Vancouver), CBC's Tapestry with Don Hill, CBC's The Arts Today with Eleanor Wachtel
about Galileo's Mistake
in Real Audio and MP3 format


Purchase Galileo's Mistake (US edition) online at: Amazon.com

Galileo's Mistake: A New Look at the Epic Confrontation between Galileo and the Church
by Wade Rowland

REVIEWS OF GALILEO'S MISTAKE

Toronto Star book review of Galileo's Mistake - A New Look at the Epic Confrontation between Galileo and the Church by Wade Rowland

Book Review by the Toronto Star of Galileo's Mistake

Review by Philip Marchand, Book Critic
Toronto Star newspaper

Author tackles myth of persecuted scientist

Everyone knows the story of Galileo. He's the genius scientist who was found guilty of heresy by the Inquisition because he claimed the earth moved around the sun, instead of vice-versa.

It's a great story, one of the "defining narratives of modern western culture," as Wade Rowland puts it in his new book, Galileo's Mistake: The Archaeology Of A Myth. Too bad, for the sake of the story, that Galileo wasn't burned at the stake - that would have made it perfect. We would have had a truly dramatic martyr for scientific truth and freedom of the intellect, crushed by the forces of darkness, as embodied in the Catholic Church.

There are a few problems with this story, however. One problem, as Rowland points out, is the reality of "the Church's historically tolerant attitude towards science." What was it about Galileo that over-rode that attitude? Is it possible that, in this famous controversy, the Catholic Church actually had good reasons for viewing the writings of Galileo with suspicion?

Yes, Rowland answers. The truth behind the trial of Galileo, as narrated in Galileo's Mistake, is a good deal more complicated and interesting than the myth.

To challenge that myth is an ambitious undertaking, and at first sight it is curious that Rowland, would undertake it. His career began with a job at the Winnipeg Free Press, and includes a 15-year stint, on and off, with CTV news. "I'm a journalist and I have been all my life, but I've also had two careers, in a sense," he comments. "I've always believed in working with your hat on. That means being prepared to quit, if need be, on a matter of principle. This is why I've always had a back-up career."

In Rowland's case, that back-up career has been writing books. His first was The Pollution Guide in 1971, based on a series of articles he wrote for the now defunct Telegram. "There was a period when I was doing a book a year," he recalls. Not that his books - the more recent ones, in particular - have been quickies. His previous book, for example, was Ockham's Razor: A Search For Wonder In An Age Of Doubt, in which he grappled with some of the issues in Galileo's Mistake, such as the limitations of scientific knowledge. To arm himself for this study, he obtained an M.A. in philosophy from Trent University, and he is currently completing his Ph.D.

"I'll be damned if I'm going to drop dead without being a little smarter than I have been most of my life," he comments. "I would like to figure out a few things first."

That's the job of philosophy all right, figuring out things. "I've always been interested in it, ever since I was at university for the first time, many years ago," Rowland says. "But I didn't know a lot about post-modernism and hermeneutics and deconstruction and all that stuff. I don't find it very useful, but it's good to know the lingo and to be able to argue with people. I'm an old-fashioned analytic philosopher."

His study of philosophy has had a few side benefits, apart from helping him writing books such as Galileo's Mistake. Rowland, who lives in Port Hope with his wife - his two grown children live in Toronto - comments, "I told my children the reason you go to university is not to get a job but to learn things that can protect you from your job, so you can stay sane. That was my way of staying sane all these years in journalism, being interested in this sort of thing."

So what was Galileo's mistake? Obviously, it was not asserting that the earth revolves around the sun, although Galileo did, perhaps, assert this a bit too loudly at a time when all the evidence was not yet in. The Church was right to remind Galileo, at the time, that the theory of the earth moving around the sun was a hypothesis that had not yet been proven.

But Galileo made an even more serious mistake, according to Rowland. He believed that science could tell the ultimate truth about nature. Today, however, we are coming to realize that scientific "truths" are like models of reality. The hypotheses of scientists may be successful in explaining how certain things work, and predicting certain outcomes, but they can never fully grasp the essence of reality, even physical reality.

"Scientific hypotheses may be successful, but our reason will never be able to tell us whether they are true," Rowland writes in Galileo's Mistake. "Truth is a metaphysical issue - beyond physics - and it involves such questions as meaning and purpose, which are unquantifiable and therefore not amenable to scientific analysis."

In other words, science will never reveal the mind of God. "The real crux of the disagreement between the church and Galileo was Galileo's assertion that, given time and research, it's possible for science to know everything there is to know - it would even be possible for science to know what God knows," Rowland comments. "The Church said, `Oh no you don't. You've built some interesting models here, but there's something to know beyond the model.'"

So the church rapped Galileo on the knuckles. Contrary to myth, it did not threaten him with torture. It punished him afterwards by putting him under house arrest for a few months - in an apartment in a luxurious palace. Afterwards, Galileo went about his business. Rowland also maintains that Galileo was perfectly sincere when he recanted his beliefs before the Inquisition because, quite simply, he saw the Church's point.

Rowland even doubts an apology to Galileo, as offered a few years ago by the Pope, is all that necessary. "I feel personally that they have gone too far in apologizing to Galileo," he says. "I think the Pope went too far in saying the clerics didn't understand what they were doing. But who's going to believe him if he tried to argue the Church was right? So from a political point of view, he's doing the best he can."

Rowland himself is not worried that he will be seen as an apologist for the Catholic Church. He's not a Catholic, for one thing. "I'm not even particularly religious," he says. "I'm just a journalist. I approach this as a journalist who has a puzzling case to decide, and in my view, in this case the Church comes out on top."

Book review by the Toronto Star newspaper



Other Book Reviews of Galileo's Mistake:






Galileo's Mistake:
Title: Galileo's Mistake
Subtitle: A New Look at the Epic Confrontation between Galileo and the Church
Author: Wade Rowland
Publication Date: July 2003
ISBN: 1559706848
Hardcover: 320 pages
List Price: $25.95 US
Publisher: Arcade Publishing


For details on the Canadian edition of Galileo's Mistake, published by Thomas Allen Publishers, click here.



Home Page | Galileo's Mistake | Ockham's Razor | Spirit of the Web | Reviews | Author Bio | Events & Readings


Copyright © 1999-2003 Wade Rowland Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Web site by Blue Cat Design.