"Rowland's is an audacious position"
The New York Times
"With easy erudition...Competently laying out the science and the overarching philosophical issues, Rowland shows that Galileo's "mistake" was his failure to recognize the larger implications of his position."
"gripping story of Galileo's trial"
International Herald Tribune
"Rowland's triumph is in examining Galileo's method over his facts and winning an argument that was lost more than 350 years ago. His book provides a fascinating contribution to a debate that is particularly germane today and is likely to be equally important 300 years from now."
"I recommend it strongly. Rowland tells the story well and with style and...backed by serious research and sensitivity to the issues. The history is embedded in a modern-day travelogue, interspersed with musings about the meaning of life."
The Globe and Mail
"An excellent mixture of science and philosophy."
David Pitt, Bookloons
"Galileo's Mistake is a lofty and ambitious philosophical exploration, and Rowland's considerable gifts as a writer make the book pleasurable and captivating. Rowland skilfully weaves history, biography, science writing, and philosophical overviews into the comfortable familiarity of a travel narrative."
"Galileo's Mistake has the lazy ease of a multi-course Italian dinner, at once relaxing and enriching".
Robert Wiersema, Quill & Quire
"...a superb work...an ambitious, even heroic, interpretation of the Galileo-Church controversy. Rowland has included a wonderfully accurate, exquisitely painted presentation of the political, cultural, and historical setting in which the Galileo-Church debate finds a clearly natural location."
B. J. Hodgson, PhD, Trent University Faculty of Philosophy
of Wade Rowland
by CKNW Radio (Vancouver), CBC's Tapestry with Don Hill, CBC's The Arts Today with Eleanor Wachtel
about Galileo's Mistake
in Real Audio and MP3 format
Purchase Galileo's Mistake (US edition) online at: Amazon.com
Galileo's Mistake: A New Look at the Epic Confrontation between Galileo and the Churchby Wade Rowland
REVIEWS OF GALILEO'S MISTAKE
Quill and Quire book review
"Veteran journalist Wade Rowland follows up the success of Ockham's Razor with another examination of the conflict between science and faith. In Galileo's Mistake, Rowland ventures to the very roots of that schism and challenges one of the key philosophical beliefs of the intervening centuries - the assumption that science can provide a definitive (or "true") perspective on the nature of reality.
The book examines the 1633 heresy trial that ended with Galileo's recantation of his telescopic discoveries, including his evidence for Copernicus's controversial theory that Earth and the other planets revolve around the sun. Prior to the trial, the Church was at the centre of scientific inquiry - in fact, Galileo borrowed some of his data from Jesuit astronomers. The recantation was a pyrrhic victory for the Church, and marked the separation of "enlightened" science and "anti-intellectual" religion in the public perception. That perception continues to this day.
Galileo's Mistake is a lofty and ambitious philosophical exploration, and Rowland's considerable gifts as a writer make the book pleasurable and captivating. Rowland skilfully weaves history, biography, science writing, and philosophical overviews into the comfortable familiarity of a travel narrative.
The pacing of Galileo's Mistake has the lazy ease of a multi-course Italian dinner, at once relaxing and enriching. Potentially difficult philosophical ideas are explored through both Socratic dialogue and Rowland's responses to historical documents and contemporary analyses. It's an effective and surprisingly uncontrived approach, resulting in a return of specialized scientific and theoretical concepts to a mainstream audience, an achievement for which Rowland deserves considerable recognition."
Book Review: Quill and Quire: Robert Wiersema, a writer and
bookseller in Victoria, B.C.
The New York Times - Books of the Times Review"Rowland's is an audacious position... in 1992 the church itself admitted that it had erred in condemming Galileo. As headlines mockingly put it at the time, the Vatican had finally acknowledged that the Earth revolved around the Sun. But to Mr. Rowland such descriptions trvialize the real issues at stake in the conflict, namely the essential nature of the universe and which sphere - science or faith - can better grasp it."
Book Review: The New York Times - Books of the Times Review
"The author puts Galileo's life and work in a historical and philosophical context to demonstrate just how revolutionary he really was (and, in some respects, wasn't). We come to know the many faces of Galileo -- the father, the husband, the music lover, the scientist -- and we come to a greater understanding of the fundamental mistake that got him in so much trouble: his stubborn, unrelenting insistence that science, and only science, reveals the true nature of the world. His refusal to accept, even for the sake of argument, the value of other belief systems (say, religion) is what did him in. And his 1633 trial, at the hands of the Inquisition, was not really about his scientific work; it was about the very nature of truth itself. An excellent mixture of science and philosophy."
Review: David Pitt, Bookloons
"Popular history recounts Galileo's 17th-century battle with Catholic leaders in stark terms. Galileo, good. Church, bad. Legend has it that the trial of the noted astronomer in 1633 was based on whether the Earth moved around the sun, as Galileo asserted, or was orbited by the sun, the church's view. But the image of an enlightened Galileo fighting for truth against the intolerant Catholic Church over astronomical concepts is far too simplistic, Wade Rowland writes in Galileo's Mistake."
Review: Philadelphia Inquirer
Read the complete book review of Galileo's Mistake by the Philadelphia Inquirer.
Other Book Reviews of Galileo's Mistake:
|For details on the Canadian edition of Galileo's Mistake, published by Thomas Allen Publishers, click here.|