Galileo's Mistake - A New Look at the Epic Confrontation between Galileo and the Church by Wade Rowland

Praise for Galileo's Mistake:

"...fresh and compelling."
Vancouver Sun

"Well-presented scientific history with an interesting philosophical twist"
Kirkus Reviews

"Rowland's is an audacious position"
The New York Times

"Rowland's triumph is in examining Galileo's method over his facts and winning an argument that was lost more than 350 years ago. His book provides a fascinating contribution to a debate that is particularly germane today and is likely to be equally important 300 years from now."
Montreal Gazette

"I recommend it strongly. Rowland tells the story well and with style and...backed by serious research and sensitivity to the issues. The history is embedded in a modern-day travelogue, interspersed with musings about the meaning of life."
The Globe and Mail

"Rowland does an impressive job of bringing the 17th century to life...he builds a compelling case that Galileo and the Church differed over something far more important than whether the earth revolved around the sun-they differed on the very nature of truth and how mortals can come to know it."
Publishers Weekly

"An excellent mixture of science and philosophy."
David Pitt, Bookloons

"Galileo's Mistake is a lofty and ambitious philosophical exploration, and Rowland's considerable gifts as a writer make the book pleasurable and captivating. Rowland skilfully weaves history, biography, science writing, and philosophical overviews into the comfortable familiarity of a travel narrative."

"Galileo's Mistake has the lazy ease of a multi-course Italian dinner, at once relaxing and enriching".
Robert Wiersema, Quill & Quire

"...a superb ambitious, even heroic, interpretation of the Galileo-Church controversy. Rowland has included a wonderfully accurate, exquisitely painted presentation of the political, cultural, and historical setting in which the Galileo-Church debate finds a clearly natural location."
B. J. Hodgson, PhD, Trent University Faculty of Philosophy

Listen to interviews
of Wade Rowland

by CKNW Radio (Vancouver), CBC's Tapestry with Don Hill, CBC's The Arts Today with Eleanor Wachtel
about Galileo's Mistake
in Real Audio and MP3 format

Purchase Galileo's Mistake (US edition) online at:

Galileo's Mistake: A New Look at the Epic Confrontation between Galileo and the Church

by Wade Rowland

Chapter One (cont'd - part 3)

The popular conception of the confrontation and the trial that was its culmination has, indeed, changed little in the more than 350 years since it took place. The Church's victory at the trial with Galileo's conviction was a Pyrrhic one, and the scientist's controversial ideas won an overwhelming triumph in the wider war. It is the victors who write the history of wars, and so it was the heroic picture of Galileo as a lonely champion of enlightenment and the Church as a blind, despotic power, hostile to scientific inquiry, that has come down to us.

If the familiar myth of Galileo as the paladin of truth and freedom opposing a venal and closed-minded Church is untrue as I have asserted, what really happened between Galileo and the Church back in the seventeenth century?

A central issue in the events surrounding the trial was the Copernican hypothesis, the idea that the Earth moved with both diurnal rotations and annual revolutions around the Sun. Galileo's supposed 'heresy' lay - at least nominally - in advocating Copernicanism in the face of apparently contradictory Biblical passages.

The hypothesis, as everybody knows, is correct. What is not so widely known, however, is that there was no convincing proof of its correctness in Galileo's time. Even less well-known is the fact that, despite this lack of solid evidence, many in the Church - perhaps a majority in its leadership - shared Galileo's view that it was very likely true.

The interesting question that arises out of this historical fact is why did the Church formally and vehemently reject Copernicanism, even though it harboured strong suspicions of its validity?

To ask that question is to begin to realize that Galileo's dispute with the Church was not about Copernicanism per se. In other words, it was not about whether the Earth moves. What, then was it about? The answer to that question is the subject matter of this book, but it can be stated here in a nutshell.

The dispute was over two conflicting views of the nature of truth and reality and about the roles religion and science ought to play in defining the world we live in. Of far more fundamental concern to the Church than the details of the Copernican hypothesis was Galileo's belief in the reality of number, his conviction that the universe was essentially a mathematical entity, in some literal way composed of numbers.

The Church, bolstered by Plato, Aristotle and nearly two thousand years of theological thought, denied this, on grounds that it excluded the possibility that there was an ultimate goal and purpose to existence. For the Church, a mathematical, mechanistic interpretation of nature could never be more than a model, an intellectual artifact. Between theory and reality there would always be a gap that could not be bridged by human reason.

Galileo and his opponents in the Church understood the true nature of their dispute very clearly and explicitly; it is the modern myth of Galileo that loses sight of its real significance. The argument about the nature of reality and what we can truly know nevertheless remains the principal bedevilment of modern civilization, for as Rousseau said, what we think we know, but do not, harms us far more than what we do not know.

It is here, in this implacable difference of opinion, that we can identify in its most basic form what I have called Galileo's mistake.

-- from Chapter 1, Galileo's Mistake
Copyright © 2001 Wade Rowland.

Galileo's Mistake:
Title: Galileo's Mistake
Subtitle: A New Look at the Epic Confrontation between Galileo and the Church
Author: Wade Rowland
Publication Date: July 2003
ISBN: 1559706848
Hardcover: 320 pages
List Price: $25.95 US
Publisher: Arcade Publishing

For details on the Canadian edition of Galileo's Mistake, published by Thomas Allen Publishers, click here.

Home Page | Galileo's Mistake | Ockham's Razor | Spirit of the Web | Reviews | Author Bio | Events & Readings

Copyright © 1999-2003 Wade Rowland Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Web site by Blue Cat Design.